Key Takeaways
|
What if your DNA says you should have a disease but you don’t? In most cases a genetic predisposition only increases the chances of developing a condition, it doesn’t guarantee it. However, certain genetic variants, especially those linked to a severe, early-onset disease such as sickle cell disease or cystic fibrosis, have been treated as fate: inherit the genetic variants, and the disease follows. But a small, growing body of research is complicating that picture. Scientists are finding people who carry genetic variants that should cause severe conditions and yet these people are healthy.
These rare, resilient individuals have “escaped” their fate. Figuring out why is starting to reshape how we think about genetics and how new treatments can be discovered.
The Search for Genetic “Escapers”
Very often scientists study sick people to find the DNA changes behind their disease. Studying healthy people to find genetic changes that protect against disease can be much harder, since finding a handful of resilient people can mean sorting through hundreds of thousands of genomes.
The first large effort to do this, called the Resilience Project, screened data from 589,306 people (the majority of whom were consented 23andMe research participants) and found 13 adults carrying genetic variants for 8 severe childhood conditions who never developed symptoms.
Since then, similar searches have turned up similar results. A 2026 study of more than 9,600 healthy adults in Singapore found nine people carrying variants associated with severe conditions such as limb-girdle muscular dystrophy and hereditary spastic paraplegia that typically appear in infancy or childhood. Several studies have found a strikingly consistent pattern: for any given disease-associated gene that’s screened, between one and three resilient individuals turn up per 10 million people. That is rare, but real.
What Might Help Someone Escape?
So what might separate an “escaper” from someone who develops the disease their DNA predicts? Researcher points to a few overlapping explanations, from additional genetic variants that may cancel out the damage, to differences in how actively a gene is expressed in the first place, to the environment a person lives in.
Protective Genetic Variants
“Escapers” may have additional genetic variants elsewhere in their DNA that counteract a disease-causing variant. A notable example is sickle cell disease. Some people carry a variant in the BCL11A gene that keeps a fetal form of hemoglobin switched on into adulthood, offsetting the effect of the sickle cell variant. This discovery helped lead to new, approved gene-editing treatment for sickle cell disease.
Another example was found looking at people who had naturally very low LDL cholesterol and a subsequent low risk for heart disease. It turns out these people had genetic variants that lower the expression of the PCSK9 gene. This discovery led to the development of a class of cholesterol-lowering drugs that’s often used to treat people with genetic variants that lead to very high cholesterol (known as familial hypercholesterolemia). In rare cases there are “escapers” who carry both familial hypercholesterolemia variants and protective PCSK9 changes and end up with cholesterol levels that are milder than expected.
Variable Activation
A second, more surprising, explanation for how “escapers” manage to stay healthy could involve how actively each copy of a gene gets used. For most genes you inherit one copy from each parent, and it was assumed both copies are equally active. However, that’s not necessarily true.
The best-known example of this is X-inactivation. For those with two X chromosomes, each cell randomly shuts off one of them early in development. Something similar, though far less understood, appears to happen with genes on the other 22 pairs of chromosomes we carry. In some cells, one parent’s copy of a gene can be turned up while the other is turned down, a phenomenon called autosomal random monoallelic expression, or aRMAE.
If you inherit one healthy copy of a gene and one disease-causing copy, which copy is more active in a given cell type can make the difference between staying healthy and developing disease. Depending on how it’s measured, as many as 50% of our genes may show this kind of activity bias.
Environment and Lifestyle
Finally, environment and lifestyle can shift the odds for people carrying a disease-causing variant. Take the case of a 75-year-old individual who is cognitively healthy despite carrying a variant for a dominantly inherited form of Alzheimer’s disease that typically causes symptoms decades earlier, particularly in his family. Researchers suspect his resilience may trace back to years of heavy heat exposure earlier in life, which may have raised his levels of heat shock proteins, a class of proteins that help cells clear out misfolded proteins like the ones that build up in Alzheimer’s disease.
Most of us won’t stumble into that kind of protection by accident, and you don’t need an extreme lifestyle to benefit from this idea. Many everyday genetic predispositions, not just rare ones, respond to the basics: a healthy diet, quality sleep and regular exercise.
Why This Research Matters
Resilient individuals remind us that there are many exceptions to genetic rules. Genetics can’t always predict with 100% certainty who will get sick. Looking at healthy individuals, and individuals from diverse genetic backgrounds, can help us find new potential treatments that may benefit us all.
At 23andMe, important advances in genetics research start with the participation of customers like you. Join our research community.
